Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Hamilton County jury awards Catoosa woman $3.3 million in health care liability case over botched surgery

Staff file photo / A courtroom is seen empty during jury deliberations at the Hamilton County Courthouse. A jury found in favor of Kellianne Goodnight across the street in Circuit Court.
Staff file photo / A courtroom is seen empty during jury deliberations at the Hamilton County Courthouse. A jury found in favor of Kellianne Goodnight across the street in Circuit Court.


A Catoosa County woman was awarded more than $3.3 million by a Hamilton County jury after a doctor at Chattanooga Skin and Cancer Clinic left a “huge, deep, irreparable and completely unnecessary crater” on her face, according to attorney Alix Michel.

Kellianne Goodnight was awarded $1.5 million for permanent disfigurement, $800,000 for past pain and suffering, $500,000 for future pain and suffering, $500,000 for past and future loss of the ability to enjoy life and $150,000 to cover medical care and services, Michel said.

The jury returned the verdict Aug. 23 after Goodnight sued the facility and its doctors for alleged negligence, according to the complaint.

The Hamilton County Circuit Court clerk’s office confirmed a verdict was reached, but the judgment document had not been filed or made available to the public as of Friday morning. A voicemail was left Thursday morning with Ann Rigsby, the Chattanooga Skin and Cancer Clinic’s officer manager. She did not respond to a request for comment.