Skip to main content
Thursday, November 19, 2026Nov 19

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Opinion: Pizzeria’s refusal to cater gay weddings is about bigotry, not beliefs

Staff file photo / A Sweet Thai Chicken pizza cooks in the oven at Pizzeria Cortile on Wednesday, Dec. 20, 2017 in Chattanooga, Tenn.
Staff file photo / A Sweet Thai Chicken pizza cooks in the oven at Pizzeria Cortile on Wednesday, Dec. 20, 2017 in Chattanooga, Tenn.

Before this week, many had never heard of Red Bank’s Pizzeria Cortile, but after the restaurant confirmed its refusal to cater gay weddings, amid Reddit-fueled hearsay, the pizza maker finds itself in the local spotlight, garnering staunch criticism, rightly so, for its blatant homophobia.

But much like the infamous U.S. Supreme Court case of the Colorado bakery that refused to design a cake for a gay couple, some have defended the pizzeria’s right to stand by their beliefs. The restaurant took this position after a flood of online criticism ensued when the pizzeria confirmed, via a DM with a customer, of its anti-gay catering practices.

“Recently, we made the difficult decision not to cater a wedding due to our personal beliefs,” the pizzeria said in a social media post. “This belief comes from a place of personal conviction, one we know is not shared by everyone, and it is one we hold without judgment toward others.”

(READ THE FREE PRESS OPINION: Should caterers be forced to serve a same-sex wedding?)

Of course, it’s ideal for anyone to not feel persecuted for their beliefs. No one wants to feel guilt or shame from an attack on their personal convictions. But this is not a personal matter. The word “belief” is carrying too much water.