Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: A ruling for the law: The Supreme Court of Israel protects the independent judiciary

File photo/Avishag Shaar-Yashuv/The New York Times / Demonstrators walk near Israel's Supreme Court building in Jerusalem on March 27, 2023.
File photo/Avishag Shaar-Yashuv/The New York Times / Demonstrators walk near Israel's Supreme Court building in Jerusalem on March 27, 2023.

That the Supreme Court of Israel issued its decisive opinion knocking down the narrow governing coalition of Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu’s terrible plan to undermine the country’s independent judiciary in the midst of a national mobilization for a war with Hamas is exactly what independent judges are supposed to do.

The ruling, the correct one, will strengthen judicial power and help keep elected government accountable. Just as the laws of war must be obeyed on the battlefield, as Israel fights a terrorist group that routinely violates those accepted norms by intentionally targeting civilians, taking hostages, and using rape and sexual violence as weapons, the law and the courts in civilian life must continue even in time of national emergency.

Netanyahu’s court proposal, to remove the Supreme Court’s authority to abrogate governmental decisions if found by the court to be “unreasonable in the extreme” was bitterly denounced by Israelis, who marched in protest by the hundreds of thousands.

But in July, Netanyahu pushed it into enactment by the Knesset, as opposition members boycotted the vote.

The case was then heard by the court on Sept. 12. Normally, high court matters are handled by a panel of five or more judges. However, this time, in an unprecedented situation, all 15 judges participated. The hearing lasted for more than 13 hours and was broadcast nationwide. Then, less than a month later, Hamas struck and Israel plunged into war.