Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Breakpoint: Liberty in the crosshairs

In December 1791, the Bill of Rights was ratified by the United States. Though these 10 amendments to the Constitution are rarely mentioned after high school civics class, recent events here and abroad offer a glimpse of life without those rights and a reminder why they are so important as a defense against ideological overreach.

If a proposed new law passes the legislative process in Ireland, the famous Irish gift of gab will require government approval. As Kristen Waggoner of Alliance Defending Freedom recently noted in Newsweek, this potential restriction is, at best, vague. Even though it targets “hate,” it never defines what “hate” is.

As she put it, “How is the public to know what kind of speech could be subject to prosecution? Given that ‘hate’ is an impossible word to define in law (and is not defined in this bill), this paves the way for basically any expression considered unfavorable to be prosecuted in the future.”

Vagueness in a national law is, in practice, an open invitation for state-based abuse, yet that is not this particular law’s only problem. If it goes forward, refusing to give the police your password if they have a search warrant will be treated as a crime, and merely possessing material that “is likely to incite violence or hatred” might get you two years in jail. In other words, according to this proposed law, a crime doesn’t even have to involve actually hating anyone or saying something that could be hateful. Anything that the powers-that-be think could possibly be interpreted as hateful would be sufficient. It’s no wonder Waggoner added, “[I]t’s not hard to imagine Ireland rapidly descending into an authoritarian state with the passage of this law.”

Back in June, Pauline O’Reilly of the Green Party defended the proposed law with a line directly out of the totalitarian playbook: “We are restricting freedom, but we’re doing it for the common good.” This would include curtailing rights guaranteed in the Irish constitution “if people’s views on others cause them deep discomfort.” Again, under this view, no crime has to be committed, if someone is caused “deep discomfort.” This kind of scrutiny will, of course, target some and not others. To paraphrase George Orwell’s great line from “Animal Farm,” all discomfort is equally wrong, but some are more equal than others.