Skip to main content
Thursday, November 12, 2026Nov 12

Former Hamilton County EMT granted new trial on vehicular homicide, driving under the influence charges

Staff photo by Olivia Ross / Justin Whaley, who was convicted of vehicular homicide in a wrong-way crash, listens during a hearing in May. Whaley was granted a new trial on certain charges in connection with the case.
Staff photo by Olivia Ross / Justin Whaley, who was convicted of vehicular homicide in a wrong-way crash, listens during a hearing in May. Whaley was granted a new trial on certain charges in connection with the case. Staff photo by Olivia Ross / Justin Whaley, who was convicted of vehicular homicide in a wrong-way crash, listens during a hearing in May. Whaley was granted a new trial on certain charges in connection with the case.

A former Hamilton County paramedic who was convicted of vehicular homicide was granted a new trial after two Soddy-Daisy officers brought new evidence to light that may have resulted in a different verdict.

Justin Whaley, 43, was sentenced to nine years in prison in connection with a 2018 wrong-way crash that killed James Brumlow on Highway 111.

Whaley was found guilty in October of seven of the eight charges against him. On Thursday, Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Boyd Patterson ordered that he be given a new trial on the charges of vehicular homicide by intoxication and driving under the influence.

His five remaining convictions, which include reckless vehicular homicide, will remain in place, an order granting partial relief states.

Document