Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Former Hamilton County deputy accused of repeated abuses of power nears trial or settlement in lawsuits

Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Former Hamilton County Sheriff's Office Deputy Daniel Wilkey leaves the courtroom May 12 after a hearing at the Courts Building in Chattanooga.
Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Former Hamilton County Sheriff's Office Deputy Daniel Wilkey leaves the courtroom May 12 after a hearing at the Courts Building in Chattanooga.

Former Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office Deputy Daniel Wilkey, who allegedly abused his power on multiple occasions during his employment with the county, is moving toward trial or settlement in lawsuits against him.

Wilkey is being sued over two separate 2019 traffic stops — one in which he allegedly coerced Shandle Riley into being baptized and another where he allegedly performed a roadside cavity search on James Mitchell.

The former deputy sought a ruling from a judge in his favor without a full trial, known as a summary judgment, or to be awarded a form of immunity that shields law enforcement and other officials from being held responsible in civil lawsuits for reasonable incidents that occur while in the line of duty, known as qualified immunity, but was denied either in both cases.

The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday dismissed Wilkey’s qualified immunity defense in the case brought by Riley, who has since died but whose family is carrying on the case.

The week prior, the appeals court also upheld a decision to deny Wilkey and former Deputy Bobby Brewer qualified immunity from Mitchell’s excessive force and failure to intervene claims. Both deputies’ appeal for summary judgment on Mitchell’s claims for assault, battery and negligence were dismissed.