As Congress revisits the notion of banning TikTok over security concerns and potential influence on the 2024 elections, it is crucial to widen our lens to include the equally concerning dynamics at X, formerly Twitter, under Elon Musk’s ownership.
Although a forced sale of X, given its U.S. ownership, is not on the table, ignoring the platform’s threats simply because of this difference is a grave oversight. I’m a political influencer on X and TikTok, and it is clear to me that should Americans lose access to TikTok, X’s role in the digital discourse landscape will only expand.
Musk’s tenure at X has been marked by promotion of far-right ideologies, the monetization of disinformation and censorship. Musk has not only promoted figures associated with white supremacy and platforms aligned with Donald Trump but has also banned journalists and enacted policies that stifle dissenting voices.
Critics of the proposed TikTok “ban” — in actuality, the bill that passed the U.S. House would require a forced sale of the Chinese-owned app — have lauded the transparency of X’s algorithm as a solution to concerns over platform manipulation.
However, Musk has made clear, simply publishing the algorithm of a social media platform does little to correct its biases. For example, Musk has demanded that the X algorithm overamplify his own posts. Given that Musk’s feed is essentially a cesspool of far-right conspiracy theories and disinformation about the national migrant crisis, forcing this content into users’ feeds is essentially a massive in-kind donation to Trump’s re-election campaign. Algorithm aside, X has also created a monetary incentive for viral disinformation through its new policy of paying “verified” users for engagement.