Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Restaurant Scene: There’s pickles on my New York-style pizza!

Staff Photo by Tierra Hayes / Pictured Friday is the Frankie Pickles pizza from Goodfella's Pizzeria.
Staff Photo by Tierra Hayes / Pictured Friday is the Frankie Pickles pizza from Goodfella's Pizzeria.

Yes, when it comes to New York-style pizza, I’m an unabashed purist. (Blame my Bronx-born father for making me this way.)

I’m so much of a purist that I believe not even toppings like traditional pepperonis belong on a slice of New York-style pizza, let alone black olives, ham or mushrooms. I love black olives, ham and mushrooms on other types of pizza, particularly from Pizza Hut with its original pan crust. But when it comes to New York-style pizza, anything other than cheese is a travesty.

(READ MORE: Zarzour’s might last forever)

My conviction was evident in the piece I wrote a few weeks ago about the plain cheese slice from Pizza Bros. I pointed out a crucial detail, how when performing “the fold,” the slice’s tip didn’t droop and how it transported me mentally back to waiting in line at Victorio’s on 145th Street in Harlem.

However, since it is Chattanooga Pizza Week I figured it was the most opportune time to stop being so stubborn and come to grips with the idea of toppings being on a slice of pizza that calls itself “New York-style.”