Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Dear Abby: Offer to repay favor has more strings than a marionette

Dear Abby can help. / Getty Images
Dear Abby can help. / Getty Images

DEAR ABBY: I helped a friend by giving her rides to and from work for two weeks while her car was being repaired. When she got her car back, she told me to let her know if she could ever repay the favor by helping me.

Recently, my car needed repairs, so I asked if I could cash in the favor for a ride to and from work for a few days. She replied that she could do that for me, but I should know she had already “paid the favor (owed to me) forward” by helping out one of her other friends, so she felt she didn’t owe me a favor any longer. I also got the impression that, if she gave me rides to work, I would owe her a new favor. I told her to forget that I asked and I’d find another way to get to work.

Is there some rule of etiquette that says you should tell someone you are “paying a favor forward” and no longer owe them a favor? — ANNOYED IN THE SOUTH

DEAR ANNOYED: If there is, this is the first I have heard of it. The “friend” you describe is what they call a “bean counter,” or a “scorekeeper.” This is someone who places excessive emphasis on controlling things, like expenditures, budgets and, in her case, relationships. Folks like that are best avoided.

DEAR ABBY: I often wonder why men don’t care for their children like women do. In my lifetime, I have known only one man who changed diapers, did naps and baths, took kids to day care or school, attended most events in the child’s life and was there for the child 24 hours a day. (He’s the man I married.) Most men I know think all of the above are the woman’s responsibility alone, even if she works full time. I can only assume it dates back to cavemen days or life on the prairie. — VALUED IN INDIANA