Apple Inc. argued in federal court that a U.S. judge should dismiss the Justice Department’s antitrust lawsuit at an early stage because it failed to state how the iPhone maker’s alleged monopoly has harmed any consumers or developers.
The suit accuses the iPhone maker of violating antitrust laws by blocking rivals from accessing hardware and software features on its popular devices. It claims Apple has used its power over app distribution and the iPhone’s features to thwart innovations that would have made it easier for consumers to switch phones.
U.S. District Judge Julien Xavier Neals said after the hearing that he hoped to decide by January on Apple’s bid to dismiss the suit brought earlier this year by Joe Biden’s administration and attorneys general from 19 states and the District of Columbia.
“Counsel addressed pretty much every question I had,” said Neals, a Biden appointee, breaking his silence after three hours of arguments on Wednesday. “We’re really going to put a lot of effort into having a decision to you by January.”
Apple’s lawyers urged the judge to dismiss the case because of the government’s failure to argue it has any monopoly power in the smartphone market or that anyone was harmed. They also argued that Apple has a legal right to choose with whom it does business and it has no duty to boost the chances of its competitors.
