Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

‘It had to be a horrific situation for her:’ Meigs County DA releases report on deputy who drove into river with woman in backseat

Staff Photo by Ben Benton / The Meigs County Courthouse is shown in 2017 on a stormy day in Decatur, Tenn. Ninth Judicial District Attorney Russell Johnson held a news conference Monday morning at the courthouse to present the findings of an investigation into the deaths of Deputy Robert John “R.J.” Leonard Jr. and Tabitha Elexis Smith.
Staff Photo by Ben Benton / The Meigs County Courthouse is shown in 2017 on a stormy day in Decatur, Tenn. Ninth Judicial District Attorney Russell Johnson held a news conference Monday morning at the courthouse to present the findings of an investigation into the deaths of Deputy Robert John “R.J.” Leonard Jr. and Tabitha Elexis Smith.

A Meigs County grand jury determined Monday that it was a “terrible accident” when a deputy fatally drove his patrol car into the Tennessee River with a woman handcuffed in the backseat, according to a grand jury report.

Ninth Judicial District Attorney Russell Johnson held a news conference Monday morning at the Meigs County Courthouse and provided a summary report on the in-custody death of Tabitha Elexis Smith, 35, and the line-of-duty death of Sheriff’s Deputy Robert John “R.J.” Leonard Jr., 35.

Both Leonard and Smith died as a result of drowning, Johnson said. Smith couldn’t have escaped from the sinking car, as there are bars on the windows in a patrol car.

“It had to be a horrific situation for her,” Johnson said.

Johnson spoke to a courtroom of a couple dozen people a few minutes after officials finished presenting the case to a grand jury, so a public panel of Meigs County residents could independently review the information, he said.