John Maynard Keynes famously said, “Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.” The point being that, even if you’re right about where the stock market is bound to go eventually, the market doesn’t have to follow your route or timetable in getting there.
Since “Liberation Day” last week when the U.S. announced punishing new tariffs on just about every country in the world, a lot of Americans are learning a corollary to Keynes’ maxim: Donald Trump can stay irrational longer than you can remain solvent.
Over the weekend, Trump explained yet again that he sees any trade deficit as a “loss” we need to be compensated for. He believes that trade deficits are “subsidies” paid by America to other countries. His math ignores our trade surpluses in services, to the tune of a quarter trillion dollars annually. He is oblivious to the relationship of trade deficits to foreign investment in America — when we send dollars abroad for goods and services, most of those dollars ultimately come back to America. And he refuses to grasp that tariffs are taxes paid by domestic importers, not foreigners.
As many have noted, Trump’s mercantilism is one of the only policy convictions he’s held for nearly his entire adult life. Indeed, one of the administration’s favored defenses of his policies is that “Trump’s been talking about this his whole life.” Or, as Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick put it in various interviews over the weekend, “Donald Trump’s been talking about this for 35 years.” The idea seems to be that Trump’s consistency on the issue somehow makes him correct on the merits, and that he has a mandate to follow through on his views. So as Lutnick declared on CNN last week, everyone should relax and “let Donald Trump run the global economy.”
The first contention is preposterous. If a President Bernie Sanders was trying to socialize medicine or issue his own version of protectionist trade policies, the fact that he’s been consistently wrong his whole life wouldn’t persuade opponents to drop their opposition out of deference to his consistency.
