In May 2017, just a few months into the first Trump administration, I wrote a column arguing that the president’s incapacity was so obvious that he should be removed from office via the 25th Amendment to the Constitution.
Its argument did not hold up well. Donald Trump’s first-term White House remained abnormally chaotic, and Trump remained, well, himself — but relative to the initial months, his presidency stabilized sufficiently that the claim of incapacity and the call for constitutional intervention didn’t fit the facts.
My column had been written in a spirit of “this can’t go on.” But it did go on — and more than that, it went on with better outcomes in economic and foreign policy than I had thought possible, to the point that within a few years of Joe Biden (who became a more exemplary 25th Amendment case!), voters were nostalgic for Trumpian results.
There have been many moments like that for observers of the Trump phenomenon — moments when it seemed his faults were leading to some irrevocable crash, or when it seemed he was finished politically forever. Time and again, those judgments have proved premature; time and again, Trump has tempted fate and lived to tell the tale.
Which is why, when he returned to office, I vowed to avoid premature declarations of catastrophe. I would criticize, but I wouldn’t act as if everything was irrecoverable for at least the first year.
