The Social Security Trust Fund is less than a decade away from insolvency thanks to congressional and presidential inertia. The 90-year-old retirement program is so popular that the vast majority of politicians prefer to tolerate the deteriorating status quo rather than jeopardize their political futures by insisting on reforms.
Yet the program’s structural defects can’t be wished away. And new polling reveals that more Americans, particularly younger Americans, are willing to embrace changes to shore up Social Security for the long term. Elected officials should take notice.
The survey, by the Cato Institute, highlights a number of interesting points. Among them: More than half of respondents don’t know how Social Security is funded. “Less than half (45%) know that today’s workers pay for current retirees, and that future workers will pay for their benefits when they retire,” the authors note. “Nearly a quarter (23%) believe that their Social Security taxes are saved in a personal account for them.”
These misperceptions lead to confusion and help explain the program’s fiscal issues. Social Security exists as a generational wealth transfer mechanism, with the payroll taxes of current workers covering the costs of benefits for retirees. Likewise, the taxes collected from those retirees during their working lives went to support payments to members of the previous generation during their golden years.
The working-age population has shrunk in recent decades, and the worker-to-beneficiary ratio continues to fall. In 2005 there were 3.3 workers for every Social Security recipient. That number is expected to be 2.1 by 2040. Without action, the trust fund, built up over decades when the number of workers dwarfed the number of retirees, will be depleted in 2033 and payroll taxes will raise enough to fund only 77% of promised benefits.
