A student I like turns in an essay. (She brings “Crime and Punishment” to class, and her last name is Russian, which makes me think of the great-grandparents I never met who left Russia for the reasons many Jews left.) A few sentences into her essay, I know she didn’t write it.
Teachers all over the country are getting these papers, only distantly related to the question you posed — and the AI machine drags in quotations and combines words in a way a high school student never would. You’re tired, so you don’t even keep reading. The student comes in to meet with you. The website you use states it is 89% certain the paper was written by AI. Your student squirms.
Your student asks how you know for sure. She says she used AI to check her sentences. She wrote them, she insists. She says she loves to vary sentences to get the reader’s attention. OK, you say. She says she didn’t use it for the next paragraph and you should add that in the site you used and see.
So I copy and paste, and the machine says it’s 100% certain the content was generated by AI. But I still trust my student. What is teaching if you can’t?
I say: You know what? Let’s meet next week, and I’ll read the essay and see if I can generate commentary to make it better because we know there are false positives when it comes to this game of seeing if AI has been used.
