Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: In Tennessee’s Education Freedom Act, ‘every’ student doesn’t mean ‘every’

AP File Photo/George Walker IV / Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee presents his original Education Freedom Scholarship Act of 2024 on Nov. 28, 2023, in Nashville.
AP File Photo/George Walker IV / Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee presents his original Education Freedom Scholarship Act of 2024 on Nov. 28, 2023, in Nashville.

Perhaps just short of a decade ago, we recall state Sen. Todd Gardenhire, R-Chattanooga, talking to newspaper editors about the necessity to educate the children of illegal immigrants.

His theory was that if the children were going to be here, grow up here and eventually work and live here, our city, county, state and country would be better off if they had the benefit of learning English, mastering math and becoming enmeshed in the culture of this country.

At the time, Gardenhire was seeking to pass a bill that would allow in-state tuition at state universities for children of illegal immigrants born in the United States and a companion bill that would allow in-state tuition for children of illegal immigrants not born in the U.S.

Eventually, the first bill passed, and the second one didn’t, but what the state senator said made a lot of sense. Since there was no coherent plan to send the illegal immigrants back to their home countries – and we still can’t imagine the logistics involved in a Trump administration-desired plan to do so today – we ought to do the best we can to help them be productive citizens.

Gardenhire was never a bleeding heart on the issue because he had some of the same concerns about illegal immigration as some of his far right colleagues, but his reasoning was pragmatic.