Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

3 Collegedale police officers cited after giving woman choice of ride to Cleveland, Tennessee, or jail

Collegedale Police Department / Members of the Collegedale Police Department took part in an intruder drill in 2023 at Wolftever Creek Elementary School. Cleveland, Tenn., officials sent a letter to Collegedale, Tenn., officials asking them to stop "courtesy rides" from one city to the other after Collegedale officers transported a woman to a Cleveland truck stop on Dec. 9.
Collegedale Police Department / Members of the Collegedale Police Department took part in an intruder drill in 2023 at Wolftever Creek Elementary School. Cleveland, Tenn., officials sent a letter to Collegedale, Tenn., officials asking them to stop "courtesy rides" from one city to the other after Collegedale officers transported a woman to a Cleveland truck stop on Dec. 9.

Three Collegedale police officers were found to have neglected their duty when they drove a woman apparently in distress and dropped her off at a truck stop in neighboring Bradley County.

The finding came in response to a letter from Cleveland, Tennessee, officials complaining about the Collegedale officers giving “courtesy rides.” The letter, an item on the Cleveland City Council’s Jan. 29 work session agenda, alleged that Collegedale police mishandled a missing person call.

“Cleveland Police Department and EMS had to respond to this issue and find adequate care for this individual,” Cleveland City Manager Joe Fivas said in an email. “The report is pretty clear that the person was having some level of mental distress, and/or drug or alcohol-induced confusion. The Collegedale officer ended up dropping off this person to the Pilot at exit 20 in Cleveland after the officer gave the ultimatum to the woman that it was jail or Cleveland. The woman chose Cleveland.”

Collegedale officials contend the woman was not missing or having a crisis in the presence of the officers who took her to the Pilot station, according to reports provided by Collegedale authorities.

Collegedale’s assistant chief of police, Jamie Heath, said a finding of neglect of duty will still stand against the three officers involved — Cpl. Nevin Recchia and officers Thomas Craine and Shae Parmenter — and they will be required to take a crisis intervention training course.