Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Are we witnessing ‘creative’ destruction or just plain destruction?

Getty images
Getty images

When drastic disruptions bring new political leaders, policymakers respond with major changes. We’re living in such a time, even if it’s not clear how much a pandemic, rampant inflation, international strife and other events of the last half-decade contributed to the returning president’s government shake-up.

Properly executed, changes like those President Donald Trump’s team seeks are the political counterpart of Joseph Schumpeter’s “creative destruction” — the famous idea outlining how innovation and progress must sometimes come at the expense of older ways of doing things. But in other cases, what may at first look creative can be just plain destruction.

Making the proper assessment won’t be easy.

Creative destruction in the private sector, as Schumpeter might see it, is R.E. Olds inventing the moving assembly line for producing Oldsmobiles and Henry Ford installing the technique in a huge Michigan manufacturing plant. A new, transparent process redefines how cars are designed and assembled. Costs fall, prices plummet and the automobile reaches the middle classes, invigorating American life.

Still, it’s easy to notice the drawbacks first. Hundreds of small — one car at a time — carmakers bite the dust, as do a host of carriage makers and blacksmiths. Uncertainty plagues the industry as investors and workers figure out what the new world will look like. Most people are left better off, but some are seriously harmed, especially at the outset.