Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Opinion: On immigration, we must not negotiate on the far right’s terms

File photo/Gregory Bull/The Associated Press / Men seeking asylum, including Peruvians, line up as they wait to be processed after crossing the border with Mexico nearby, on April 25, 2024, in Boulevard, Calif.
File photo/Gregory Bull/The Associated Press / Men seeking asylum, including Peruvians, line up as they wait to be processed after crossing the border with Mexico nearby, on April 25, 2024, in Boulevard, Calif.

Months after the GOP supermajority in the Tennessee General Assembly passed a law that requires law enforcement to identify immigrants known to be unauthorized to the proper authorities — a bill that state Sen. Todd Gardenhire voted against — the Republican senator of Chattanooga has offered to amend the legislation.

Gardenhire, via a new bill co-sponsored by Republican state Rep. Sabi “Doc” Kumar of Springfield, wants school resource officers exempt from the original law.

“I’m going to look at every law that I can and look at the unintended consequences of what that law says,” Gardenhire told the Chattanooga Times Free Press last week. “In this case, it has a lot of unintended consequences, the way it’s written.”

The senator is correct. Not only are there are systemic and logistical issues that make the law virtually unenforceable, the legislation has the potential to deport unauthorized immigrant schoolchildren, despite foreign-born people’s constitutional right to public schooling.

But while Gardenhire is right to pursue this change, it doesn’t go far enough. The original bill should have never been passed, as it is based on a far-right, anti-immigration fantasy — a complete fiction.