Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Teenager’s family sues Hamilton County Schools over use of threats law

Staff file photo / The central offices of the Hamilton County Department of Education are in the Entreprise South Industrial Park, near the corner of Hickory Valley Road and Bonny Oaks Drive. A mother is suing the department after her son with autism was arrested under Tennessee's school threats law.
Staff file photo / The central offices of the Hamilton County Department of Education are in the Entreprise South Industrial Park, near the corner of Hickory Valley Road and Bonny Oaks Drive. A mother is suing the department after her son with autism was arrested under Tennessee's school threats law.

A mother is suing the Hamilton County Department of Education, alleging the district violated the First Amendment when it penalized her teenage son under Tennessee’s threat of mass violence law.

The 13-year-old, identified in court filings as John Doe, has autism and was arrested after he told his social studies teacher that she could not look inside his backpack or the school would “blow up.” The backpack contained a stuffed animal, which the student used as a type of security blanket, the lawsuit said.

The teenager, the lawsuit said, exaggerated to make a point while trying to regulate his emotions. He was punished for using a word, not for how he used it in context, which violates the First Amendment, the lawsuit said.

“No one believed Doe’s words were truly threatening,” the lawsuit said. “Doe was expelled simply because his words contained a magic phrase, ‘blow up.’ Expelling a student for making a comment that no one perceived as threatening is not rationally related to any legitimate state interest.”

(READ MORE: Lawsuit challenges Marion County Schools’ use of threats of mass violence law)