Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

The slow, inexorable decline of mutual funds

Christopher Hopkins
Christopher Hopkins

More investors each year are discovering the advantages of exchange-traded funds over traditional mutual funds.

Exchange-traded funds offer similar or equal diversification at a lower cost and are more tax friendly than traditional mutual funds. But mutual funds still comprise two-thirds of all fund assets due to institutional inertia in retirement plans and compensation structures for brokers selling them.

That dynamic is changing. Exchange-traded funds are gaining assets, while mutual funds are bleeding. In 2024, exchange-traded fund assets increased by over $1 trillion, while $380 billion leaked away from mutual funds. As it gets more difficult to defend a higher-cost model, the shift toward exchange-traded funds will pick up speed.

The year 1924 was a seminal one for individual investors. That year, a former cookware salesman turned stockbroker named Edward Leffler had a brainstorm. His idea was to pool the modest capital of smaller investors to purchase a common portfolio of stocks, allowing average households access to the market for the first time. The Massachusetts Investor Trust was the very first mutual fund and still exists today, the flagship of the fund giant MFS. Others soon followed, sparking the evolution of today’s multi-trillion dollar industry.

But as the venerable mutual fund celebrates its 100th birthday, its aches and pains are taking a toll. Meanwhile, there’s a younger, nimbler, smarter challenger on the scene. The superiority of exchange-traded funds over mutual funds derives from the difference in their structures, which gives exchange-traded funds a big advantage in cost and tax efficiency. The expanding panoply of exchange-traded fund offerings will ultimately capture the lion’s share of assets.