Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Some athletes’ NIL deals with collectives not holding up to new scrutiny

AP photo by Vasha Hunt / Alabama hosts Georgia in an SEC regular-season football game in September 2024 in Tuscaloosa.
AP photo by Vasha Hunt / Alabama hosts Georgia in an SEC regular-season football game in September 2024 in Tuscaloosa.

The new agency in charge of regulating name, image and likeness deals in college athletics sent a letter to schools Thursday saying it had rejected agreements between players and donor-backed collectives formed over the past several years to funnel money to athletes or their schools.

Those arrangements hold no “valid business purpose,” the memo read, and don’t adhere to rules that call for outside NIL deals to be between players and companies that provide goods or services to the general public for profit.

The letter to NCAA Division I athletic directors could be the next step in shuttering today’s version of the collective — groups that are closely affiliated with schools and that, in the early days of NIL compensation after July 2021, proved the most efficient way for schools to indirectly cut deals with players.

Since then, the landscape has changed yet again with the $2.8 billion House v. NCAA settlement that allows schools to pay the players directly via revenue sharing as of July 1.

Already, collectives affiliated with Alabama, Colorado, Georgia, Notre Dame and others have announced they’re shutting down. Georgia, Illinois and Ohio State are among those that have announced plans with Learfield, a media and technology company with decades of licensing and other experience across college athletics, to help arrange NIL deals.