One hundred years ago this month was a court case that was known as “the trial of the century,” at least until the trial of O.J. Simpson. In July 1925, hundreds of reporters descended on the small, fledgling town of Dayton, Tennessee, to cover Tennessee v. John Scopes, immortalized since as the Scopes Monkey Trial. For eight days, the small community was the center of the media world and a focus of national and international attention. Afterward, it became a bit of a staple of popular culture. For example, Johnny Cash’s song “A Boy Named Sue” was inspired by the prosecuting attorney for the state of Tennessee, Sue K. Hicks.
According to popular myth, the Scopes Trial was a climactic battle in the ongoing war between religious fundamentalism and science. At least that’s how the story was told by the loosely based play-turned-movie “Inherit the Wind.”
In reality, the whole thing was a setup. Dayton wasn’t a hotbed of fundamentalist zealotry persecuting a courageous teacher who championed science over religion. The previous year, Tennessee had passed an ordinance making it illegal to “teach any theory that denies the story of the Divine Creation of man as taught in the Bible.” The ACLU, an emerging legal organization that employed a strategy of suing laws in high-profile cases, had advertised in newspapers across Tennessee that they were looking for a defendant to challenge the law. Dayton city leaders saw the ad and, hoping to save their dying town through tourism, “volun-told” John Scopes, a local gym teacher who once substituted in a biology class. Though it’s not clear Scopes ever taught Darwinism, he became the defendant.
Supporters of the law saw evolution as an affront to human dignity and a means of undermining the faith of young people. Parents, not teachers, should determine what children are taught. The ACLU hoped to undermine religious litmus tests in education. They planned to lose the local trial so that the law could be challenged in a higher court.
William Jennings Bryan, known as the “Great Commoner,” joined the prosecution to defend the law. The three-time Democratic presidential nominee was, according to historian Edward Larson, a strange mix “of left-wing politics and right-wing religion.” Former Secretary of State under Woodrow Wilson, he was also a pacifist, a champion of popular causes such as women’s rights, a populist opponent of big business and an incredible public speaker. Though not a strict six-day creationist, he was a staunch opponent of Darwinism and a champion of parental rights.
