Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

The secret to making the best sandwiches at home

Good bread is the foundation to a great sandwich. / Dreamstime/TNS
Good bread is the foundation to a great sandwich. / Dreamstime/TNS

Like a good summer movie, a great sandwich should be full of delightful familiar ingredients sparked with a few good surprises. And like a good plot, the sandwich should be built on a sturdy foundation.

But first, let’s agree on the definition of a sandwich as opposed to a hamburger, hot dog, taco, wrap, empanada or burrito. To quote the Merriam-Webster dictionary, “a sandwich consists of two or more slices of bread or split roll having a filling in between.” (Open-faced sandwiches are a whole different category, and they deserve a story of their own.)

THE BREAD

There are few rules to govern sandwich fillings, but it’s clear that the foundation must be very good bread.

› Rye bread: A dark, dense and malty rye bread is a great match for smoked meats and the perfect platform for my hometown hero, the New Jersey Joe. The triple-decker beauty layers turkey, Swiss cheese, roast beef and coleslaw, slathered with Russian dressing on three layers of thinly sliced rye.