LOS ANGELES — The New York Islanders made some moves Friday night and maneuvered their way into three picks among the top 17 as the 2025 NHL draft got underway.
Everyone had known for nearly two months that the Islanders would be making the first selection overall, though, and they surprised nobody by using it on defenseman Matthew Schaefer.
High-scoring forward Michael Misa went second overall to the San Jose Sharks, and the Chicago Blackhawks took Swedish forward Anton Frondell third.
The Islanders, who won the draft lottery on May 5 to secure their first No. 1 selection since 2009, got things started at the Peacock Theater in downtown Los Angeles by selecting the 17-year-old Schaefer. The 6-foot-2, 183-pound blue-liner from Hamilton, Ontario, with exceptional puck-moving ability and strong defensive skills spent the past two seasons with the Ontario Hockey League’s Erie Otters.
Schaefer scored 22 points while playing in only 17 games last season before breaking his collarbone in December, but his acumen on both ends of the ice still propelled him to the top of nearly all draft boards. Schaefer is just the fifth defenseman drafted No. 1 overall since 2000, and the first since Owen Power went to the Buffalo Sabres in 2021.
Schaefer persevered through tragedy to reach this milestone. Schaefer’s mother, Jennifer, died of cancer 16 months ago, and he also endured the recent deaths of Otters owner Jim Waters and the mother of the family he lived with while playing for Erie.
So when he pulled on his Islanders sweater for the first time on the stage at the draft, he kissed a pink ribbon patch on the chest representing breast cancer awareness before breaking into tears.
“I appreciate you taking a chance on me,” Schaefer said in a video conference call with members of the Islanders front office. “I promise I won’t disappoint, but especially I just want to say to my mom and all my family and friends, thanks for everything.”
The Islanders added the patch specifically for Schaefer, along with his mother’s initials.
“Seeing the ribbon on my jersey, and I saw a picture, it has J.S. on my back here,” Schaefer said, “you can see just how high class the organization is. It really means a lot. I wish my mom could be here today. Obviously, she’s with me here in spirit. … Cancer sucks, and it’s not fun. She didn’t feel the best, but she was always the happiest in the family. She would do anything for us.”
Schaefer got two new teammates when the Islanders used the 16th pick on Swedish forward Victor Eklund and nabbed defenseman Kashawn Aitcheson with the 17th selection.
Both of Pennsylvania’s NHL teams also were busy in Los Angeles. The Philadelphia Flyers grabbed forward Porter Martone sixth overall before trading up for the 12th selection to get forward Jack Nesbitt, while the Pittsburgh Penguins maneuvered up and down the order to control three picks in the top 24, swinging two trades while drafting forwards Benjamin Kindel, Bill Zonnon and William Horcoff.
Misa tore up the OHL last season as the captain of the Saginaw Spirit, scoring 62 goals and 134 points in just 65 games. As a draft pick for the Sharks, he joins a struggling organization that chose Will Smith fourth overall in 2023 and got center Macklin Celebrini with the first overall pick a year ago.
“We just thought it was a perfect fit with what we already have here,” San Jose general manager Mike Grier said. “Another guy to step in and be a nightmare matchup for people.”
Frondell excelled as a 17-year-old forward last season with Djurgarden in Sweden’s second division, showing off a two-way game that allowed him to push Misa on some draft boards. At 6-2, he could provide a large complement to Connor Bedard.
Frondell is the eighth Swedish player to be a top-three selection, joining elite company that includes Victor Hedman, Mats Sundin and the Sedin twins.
Center Caleb Desnoyers went fourth to the Utah Mammoth, who moved up 10 spots in the draft lottery.
The Nashville Predators chose physical forward Brady Martin with the fifth pick before trading up for the 21st selection to get Kitchener defenseman Cameron Reid. Martin skipped the draft, staying home on his family farm in Ontario.
Fans of the host Los Angeles Kings inside the theater got fired up for their club to make the 24th selection — which the tam promptly traded to Pittsburgh for the 31st and 59th selections, prompting groans from the crowd. Los Angeles eventually chose defenseman Henry Brzustewicz from the Memorial Cup champion London Knights in general manager Ken Holland’s first selection for his new team.
The Penguins created the majority of the surprises in the first round, first by choosing Calgary Hitmen center Kindel with the 11th pick — much higher than many prognosticators expected.
Pittsburgh then traded the 12th pick, which originally belonged to the New York Rangers, to Philadelphia for the 22nd and 31st picks. The Flyers wanted the 6-4 Nesbitt, a fast-rising center from the OHL’s Windsor Spitfires last season.
The Penguins also gave a second-round pick to the Kings and swapped first-rounders so they could move up for Horcoff — the son of NHL veteran Shawn Horcoff — with the 24th pick.
The Anaheim Ducks took a chance on forward Roger McQueen with the 10th selection. The 6-5 McQueen is widely thought to have enough talent to become an elite center, but the Saskatchewan native has been slowed by a back injury that scared off some teams.
Two goalies were chosen in the first round for the first time since 2021 and only the third time in 13 years. The Columbus Blue Jackets grabbed Russia’s Pyotr Andreyanov with the 20th pick, making him the highest-picked European goalie in four years, while San Jose added goalie Joshua Ravensbergen with the 30th selection.
The Boston Bruins used the seventh overall pick on Boston College center James Hagens, the consensus top prospect for this draft a year ago.
Hagens, who hails from New York’s Long Island and was coveted by many Islanders fans, slid down the board just enough to reach the Bruins, whose pick was announced by a video of comic actor Adam Sandler in character as Happy Gilmore, complete with his signature Bruins jersey.
“I’m so excited to be back in Boston, and to have Adam Sandler make the pick, that was special,” said Hagens, who cites “Happy Gilmore” as his favorite movie. “I love to win, and I’m really glad that I’m in Boston.”
The Seattle Kraken chose playmaking forward Jake O’Brien eighth overall.
The draft wraps up with seven more rounds Saturday, and teams began picking Friday from a pool packed with talent — even if it is missing a few staples of recent drafts. Unlike the past two editions, there was no prohibitive lock of a No. 1 pick this year, but Schaefer clearly came out on top for most executives.
The event also lacked the centralized structure that has long been a staple of this annual exercise. The 32 teams’ various executives are mostly at home, not strewn across the draft floor. The majority of the picks were taken to a room just behind the stage to exchange televised pleasantries with executives for their new teams through video conferencing.