Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Opinion: The GOP’s obfuscation of school vouchers

File photo/Mark Humphrey/The Associated Press / People protest against school vouchers Tuesday, April 9, 2019, in Nashville, Tenn.
File photo/Mark Humphrey/The Associated Press / People protest against school vouchers Tuesday, April 9, 2019, in Nashville, Tenn.


Ever since Gov. Bill Lee and his Republican allies in the Tennessee state legislature began their eventually successful push for statewide school vouchers, the GOP has taken many measures to obfuscate the detrimental impact this will have on public education.

For instance, school voucher supporters in the legislature have insisted these are not actually vouchers and should be referred to as scholarships. While in some sense true — Tennessee’s program does institute a more indirect funding mechanism — these are, in effect, school vouchers and should be labeled as such.

What is at play here is a rhetorical strategy to distance Tennessee’s program from the well-documented negative repercussions school vouchers have had on public education. Arizona’s school voucher system is a recent and notorious example.

Another way Tennessee Republicans are working to hide the impact of school vouchers is by simply not tracking their impact at all. As Chalkbeat Tennessee recently reported, voucher recipients in Tennessee’s program will not be required to report if the student was already enrolled in a private school.