If you listen to progressive policymakers for a few minutes, you’ll likely hear that few problems on Earth can’t be solved by “taxing the rich.” Want to nationalize health care? Tax the rich. Want to close the deficit? Tax the rich. Need a ball gown for the Met Gala? Tax the rich. Unfortunately, legislators not invited to fashion shows should look elsewhere for real solutions to America’s fiscal challenges.
Let’s start with the basics: The federal tax code is already one of the most progressive in the world. According to the Joint Committee on Taxation, the U.S. tax code is highly progressive, with the bottom 50% of U.S. taxpayers facing an average federal tax rate of 6.8%. In comparison, the top 1% pays about 5 times that amount, at 34%. Note that these measures include all federal taxes, including payroll taxes, which are generally regressive, and the corporate tax, which JCT assumes primarily falls on higher-income earners.
Compared to our peers, the U.S. tax code has generally been more progressive than any other in the developed world. While many European nations raise more revenue overall, they do it by taxing everyone — including low-income households — at the register through value-added taxes. In contrast, the U.S. leans heavily on progressive income and payroll taxes, disproportionately hitting high earners.
It’s also progressive relative to income. According to the IRS, the top 1% earn 22% of total income but pay more than 40% of the nation’s income taxes. By contrast, the bottom 50% of earners collectively pay a negative share of income taxes, mainly due to refundable credits like the Earned Income Tax Credit and the Child Tax Credit. Note that these households do face other taxes, and these outcomes are by design.
The basic facts of the U.S. tax system reveal that those arguing in favor of a progressive tax system have already won — that’s what the United States has today.
