Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Opinion: ‘Hamilton’ and the lies we tell about our history

Staff Photo by Robin Rudd / Lin-Manual Miranda, played by Amir Andalib, center is haunted by the spirits of slaves, played by Marvin Parks and Ashley Noel.  A production of The Haunting of Lin-Manuel Miranda will be performed at Howard High from May 2 to May 4, 2025.
Staff Photo by Robin Rudd / Lin-Manual Miranda, played by Amir Andalib, center is haunted by the spirits of slaves, played by Marvin Parks and Ashley Noel. A production of The Haunting of Lin-Manuel Miranda will be performed at Howard High from May 2 to May 4, 2025.

When looking at the broad scope of American history, there is often a stark difference between the popular imagination of this nation’s founding and the disturbing truth of our past. In the modern era, one would be hard-pressed to find a piece of art that encapsulates that contradiction as well as the hit Broadway musical “Hamilton.”

Written by songwriter and actor Lin-Manuel Miranda and based on Ron Chernow’s 2004 biography of Founding Father Alexander Hamilton, the musical, which debuted in 2015, was met with near-universal acclaim, winning 11 Tony Awards, including Best Musical. In 2016, it won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama.

The musical delves into the life of Hamilton – over a backdrop of African American-inspired music – from his out-of-wedlock birth on a Caribbean island to his political ascendancy during the early years of the United States.

“Hamilton” depicts the man as an immigrant who makes a name for himself in revolutionary America. In a time when the chattel slavery of African Americans still existed, Hamilton is depicted as an abolitionist, a theme that is essential to the musical.

However, there’s one problem with this: It isn’t true. While many scholars conclude that Hamilton, at times, expressed general opposition to slavery, like many founding fathers, the facts of his life paint a different picture.