Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Review: Nicole Jarvis’ new Appalachian fantasy novel explores seductive nature of transgression

Photo by Katherine Addison / Nicole Jarvis
Photo by Katherine Addison / Nicole Jarvis

“A SPELL FOR CHANGE” by Nicole Jarvis (Titan Books, 448 pages, $19).

Nicole Jarvis’ new novel, “A Spell for Change,” explores what the fantasy genre looks like in a 1920 Appalachian setting. Three young people struggle to find their way in Chatuga, Tennessee. There aren’t many economic or romantic opportunities in this mountain town, but Nora Jo, Kate and Oliver are determined to make their lives bearable one way or another.

Since birth, Kate has experienced seizures accompanied by visions of the future, visions that always materialize no matter how hard she fights against them. Nora Jo thinks she’s found a way to flout rural expectations by becoming a teacher — until she’s fired and apprentices herself to a witch. Oliver has returned from the front in World War I haunted by literal and metaphorical ghosts. Jarvis skillfully plays with the fantasy trope of characters rejecting their powers at first. Often it’s hard to imagine why anyone would turn down magic. In this setting, it’s easy to understand why normal is safer.

It’s not only magic that distinguishes these three. They also skirt Chatuga’s rules and laws of conduct through their romantic interests. Nora Jo has a secret crush on a quiet farm girl named Gloria. When they confess their feelings to each other, Gloria is horrified, remembering when she was whipped by her father for kissing a girl. Kate is Black and Oliver is white in a time and place when interracial marriages are illegal, but they find themselves irresistibly drawn to each other.

Jarvis conveys the dangers for the characters in clear terms, never shying away from the realities of this era, even if the imaginative elements lend the characters more agency than they would otherwise have. One chapter from Nora Jo’s point of view explains that she “knew what the world did to those who didn’t fit in, whether it was the witch trials in Old Salem or the modern lynchings of any Black person who stepped out of line. Those who fit society got peacekeeping, the status quo. Those outside were punished with swift, brutal violence.”