Rocketeers are natural risk-takers who expect some of their launches to blow up on the pad. Running the federal government, even in search of greater efficiency, cannot be undertaken so recklessly.
Elon Musk, Donald Trump’s largest financial backer and the world’s richest man, convinced the president to create an unaccountable sub-department of government to purportedly root out waste and fraud from the federal budget. While the idea sounded appealing, the result was anything but efficient and has instead inflicted lasting damage.
At the outset, Musk promised the Department of Government Efficiency project would cut “at least $2 trillion” from the federal budget, a risible claim given that the entire discretionary portion of annual spending is only $1.8 trillion. Musk subsequently scaled back his estimate to $1 trillion. The actual results have been, to put it charitably, underwhelming.
DOGE, aptly named after an internet meme, now claims savings of just $170 billion according to its website, just 8% of its original promise. But the department’s ciphering has been riddled with errors, exaggerations and falsehoods that have annihilated its credibility. While it promised to substantiate savings on its “Wall of Receipts,” only 42% of the line items include any documentation and many of those simply read “currently unavailable.” Dozens more have been rescinded when errors were highlighted by journalists.
The chaotic assault on government brings its own costs that largely nullify the purported savings. According to the nonprofit Partnership for Public Service, rehiring essential employees fired by mistake, paid leave for furloughed personnel and lost productivity will cost taxpayers $135 billion this year alone. This figure does not include legal costs to the government to defend the numerous lawsuits challenging the legality of many of its actions.
