Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: The US is about to discover if deficits don’t matter

Photo/Jose Luis Magana/The Associated Press / Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky, questions Secretary of State Marco Rubio as he testifies before the Senate Committee on Appropriations subcommittee on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, May 20, 2025.
Photo/Jose Luis Magana/The Associated Press / Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky, questions Secretary of State Marco Rubio as he testifies before the Senate Committee on Appropriations subcommittee on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, May 20, 2025.

It’s hard to think intelligently about public debt and deficits. The economics of fiscal policy is complicated and defies straightforward prescriptions. What’s most striking about budget-making in Washington today, though, is not that legislators are confused about what good debt-management requires. It’s that they’ve just stopped thinking about it.

If passed by the Senate, last week’s vast House budget bill would add between $3 trillion and $5 trillion to deficits over the next 10 years. Yet the plan hasn’t divided the country’s politicians according to whether it’s fiscally reckless. Nowadays, that issue rarely comes up. All that matters is who gains and who loses from the proposed changes to taxes and spending. Whether the economy is heading for fiscal breakdown isn’t Washington’s concern.

In 2002, Vice President Dick Cheney famously said deficits don’t matter, noting that the national debt soared during Ronald Reagan’s time in office (from 21% of GDP to 35%) as the economy boomed. Conscientious fiscal neglect, as one might call it, is nothing new. The difference is that Cheney’s comment was provocative and meant to be: It drew attention and was argued over. Not any longer. Nobody in Congress or the White House thinks it necessary to insist that deficits don’t matter. They’ve simply stopped caring.

This suspension of fiscal anxiety might seem puzzling. Perhaps the public debt is now so big, and on such a fast-rising trajectory, that bringing it back under control seems impossibly difficult. A politician might therefore ask, why worry about it? Without this bill, debt was already on track to exceed 150% of gross domestic product by 2055. But there’s no politically feasible way to rein it in. So why not cut taxes by another few trillion dollars over the next 10 years? Sure, this will raise the debt by another 10 percentage points, but the debt was “unsustainable” anyway, so what’s your point?

It turns out that this pattern – the bigger the debt, the less likely politicians are to address it – is lurking in the data. An International Monetary Fund study in 2010 found that adjustments to fiscal policy in a group of 23 advanced economies were more sensitive to rising debt at low levels of debt than at high levels of debt; beyond a certain point an increase in debt actually resulted in a smaller change in budget policy. A new study of the U.S. found that “fiscal feedback” – the extent to which fiscal policy is tightened when projected deficits go up – has fallen markedly (alongside rapidly rising debt) since 2004.