CHARLOTTE, N.C. — A federal judge has issued a key victory for 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports, a development that further pressures NASCAR to settle the antitrust lawsuit filed against it by the two three-car teams.
NASCAR commissioner Steve Phelps said last week in a prepared statement ahead of the final national series races of the season at Phoenix Raceway that the stock-car racing series and sanctioning body is “trying our hardest” to settle the federal antitrust lawsuit with the two teams suing it, the most expansive comments yet from the defendants.
That came before Sunday’s season finale for the top-level Cup Series, which includes both 23XI — owned by Joe Gibbs Racing driver Denny Hamlin, retired NBA star Michael Jordan and Curtis Polk, the basketball legend’s longtime business manager — and Front Row, which is owned by entrepreneur Bob Jenkins.
U.S. District Judge Kenneth Bell ruled Tuesday in favor of 23XI and Front Row on an argument over the market definition of “premier stock-car racing.” Bell found that NASCAR controls the market and that NASCAR’s argument that teams can race in other series is moot.
The teams said in alleging the relevant market for premier stock-car racing teams that “NASCAR’s Cup Series is currently the only buyer.” The argument was backed by the opinion of sports economics expert Daniel Rascher, who concluded that “premier stock-car racing” is a distinct form of automobile racing, and other types of motorsports like Formula 1 and IndyCar — the international and U.S.-based open-wheel circuits, respectively — and all lower levels of stock car racing are not an equal substitute to NASCAR.
