Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: AI can perform a song, but can it make art?

Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Madison Scanlan de Salmeron, 9, sketches ideas for her own art while looking at the works of artist Nellie Mae Rowe during a spring break art camp at the Hunter Museum of American Art on Wednesday, April 5, 2023.
Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Madison Scanlan de Salmeron, 9, sketches ideas for her own art while looking at the works of artist Nellie Mae Rowe during a spring break art camp at the Hunter Museum of American Art on Wednesday, April 5, 2023.

The most insulting thing about the success of Breaking Rust, an artificial intelligence “artist” that topped Billboard’s Country Digital Song Sales Chart this week, is the titles of the hits.

“Walk My Way.”

“Living on Borrowed Time.”

The EP — which is also on the charts — is called “Resilient,” as if Breaking Rust spent years playing for tips in empty bars. And maybe Aubierre Rivaldo Taylor, who is credited for writing the songs, did. But the bluesy voice we hear singing about pain and suffering did not overcome anything.

In fact, you could say this completely computer-generated country singer found chart success by mocking people. A year ago, a handful of loud industry folks in Nashville questioned whether Beyoncé, who was born and raised in Texas, was country enough to do a country album. Good times.