Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Trump 2.0 is America’s worst moments redux

Photo/Erin Hooley/The Associated Press / Military personnel in uniform, with the Texas National Guard patch on, walk at the U.S. Army Reserve Center on Tuesday, Oct. 7, 2025, in Elwood, Ill., a suburb of Chicago.
Photo/Erin Hooley/The Associated Press / Military personnel in uniform, with the Texas National Guard patch on, walk at the U.S. Army Reserve Center on Tuesday, Oct. 7, 2025, in Elwood, Ill., a suburb of Chicago.

One way to look at much of the second Trump administration is that it is a recapitulation of some of the worst episodes in the history of the United States.

President Donald Trump’s crusade against diversity programs — his efforts to purge the federal government, private businesses and elite universities of diversity, equity and inclusion efforts — is reminiscent of the second Red Scare, the postwar effort to banish and blacklist Americans with left-wing views from positions of authority and influence in and outside government. It’s not that DEI is left wing but that the president views it as a pernicious and dangerous ideology to be rooted out by every available means, including targeting those thought to represent the drive for greater diversity in our institutions. You could also see the push to punish private citizens who refused to indulge the state’s official narrative of the life of Charlie Kirk as another moment with parallels to the Red Scare.

The president’s mass deportation program — spearheaded by the masked men and women of Immigration and Customs Enforcement — is by, his admission, an indirect callback to President Dwight Eisenhower’s Operation Wetback, a militarized campaign of intimidation and harassment aimed at the millions of Mexican immigrants who had entered the United States, many of them legally. Then, as now, federal agents crowded immigrants, legal and illegal, onto buses and planes for quick removal from the United States. Then, as now, all of this is marked by the unmistakable scent of racism.

And the immigration raids themselves, such as the one in Chicago where federal agents detained citizens, including children, for questioning, are reminiscent of the Palmer raids under President Woodrow Wilson during the first Red Scare in 1919 and 1920. The raids, ordered by Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer, saw federal agents sweep through cities such as New York, Philadelphia and Detroit, where they made warrantless arrests of thousands of suspected radicals, many of them recent immigrants. Hundreds were detained in makeshift camps with abysmal conditions. At one such location, historian Beverly Gage observes in her biography of J. Edgar Hoover, who was involved in planning the raids, 600 men were “jammed into barracks planned for 300, with no heat and dwindling food.” At another, “800 prisoners had been stuffed into a windowless corridor with only one working bathroom and no beds.”

I mention these antecedents because yet another came to mind while observing the president’s latest actions.