What is the welfare state America wants, and what is the one it can afford? This is not a question Americans are ready to discuss — so much so that their elected officials have shut down the government to avoid it.
Since the 1960s, the U.S. welfare state has grown to cover not just the poor but, increasingly, the middle class. When there is a temporary economic hardship, it tends to be used as an excuse for a permanent expansion of social insurance programs. In the broadest terms, this phenomenon explains the current shutdown.
In 2021, during the pandemic, the American Rescue Plan increased the subsidies available to people to buy health insurance on the exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act. Designed to ensure that their premiums did not exceed a certain percentage of their income, the original subsidies were available only to those who earned less than 400% of the federal poverty level. The 2021 law eliminated the 400% requirement and lowered those income percentages significantly. The more generous package was presented as an emergency measure to ensure everyone had insurance during a health crisis, and is set to expire at the end of this year.
Democrats want to make the subsidies permanent, and Republicans don’t. In a sense, the parties have switched sides: Last spring, it was Republicans who wanted to extend a program that was set to expire at the end of the year — the tax cuts passed into law in 2017. Democrats view entitlements in much the same way Republicans view tax cuts: Once in place, they become so popular they can’t be taken away.
And the subsidies are very popular, even though most Americans don’t get them because they have Medicaid, Medicare or employer-provided health insurance. The subsidies did make the exchanges more popular. Since 2021 the number of Americans enrolled in the marketplace increased from 11 million to 24 million, and 92% of them receive some subsidy. If the enhanced subsidies end, everyone on the exchange will face higher premiums.
