Call it industrial policy, state capitalism, old-fashioned socialism: It’s a bad idea. Across several recent administrations, the U.S. government’s role in the economy has grown increasingly intrusive. It’s a tried-and-failed experiment that should be scrapped before it does any more harm.
Citing a variety of goals — protecting national security, bolstering supply chains, boosting domestic manufacturing — the current administration has been giving itself “a piece of the action,” as the commerce secretary puts it, in company after company.
So far, it has taken a 10% stake in Trilogy Metals Inc.; a $400 million chunk of MP Materials Corp.; a possible 5% share of Lithium Americas Corp., along with a cut of its Thacker Pass project; a “golden share” in United States Steel Corp.; and a 10% piece of Intel Corp. It has also offered export-control exemptions to Nvidia Corp. and Advanced Micro Devices Inc. in exchange for 15% of the resulting revenue.
Decades of hard experience show the perils of such intervention. Outside of genuine emergencies, it is likely to lead to misallocated resources, slower growth, less dynamism and more rent-seeking. Far from strengthening domestic industry, it will favor incumbents over startups, delay needed reforms and restructurings, and invariably prioritize politics over productivity. It’s a formula for stifling innovation and enfeebling the competitive spirit.
Unfortunately, “state capitalism” is fast becoming formal policy in numerous respects. One recent analysis found that the U.S. now doles out nearly $200 billion in direct subsidies for favored businesses each year, thanks partly to splurges from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, the Chips and Science Act, and the Inflation Reduction Act.
