Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: The myth of Mr. Smith — Why moral exhortation doesn’t change politics

Getty Images
Getty Images

In the American political conscience, there lingers a myth: That real change comes from exhortation — passionate, unyielding exhortation — that moves the hearts of men and women. According to this story, virtuous citizens advocate relentlessly for what is right until the sheer moral force of their persistence breaks through.

This sentiment is epitomized in the classic film “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.” There, Mr. Smith spends himself on the Senate floor, filibustering without rest, shaming his colleagues, refusing to give up even when all seemed lost. And when victory finally arrives, it arrives not because the people organized and seized their rightful power, nor because of any tactical maneuvering, but because his nemesis, Senator Joseph Paine, unable to bear the lashings of his awakened conscience, succumbs in guilt and confesses defeat. The triumph is moral, almost spiritual: Conscience conquers corruption.

But politics has never worked like that — and it never can or will. In a democracy, power does not hinge on shaming the powerful into decency. It originates from the people and ultimately devolves back to them. The very notion that representatives must be begged, beseeched, or morally harangued to “do the right thing” is a misunderstanding of democracy. A true representative does not sit waiting to be moved by a grand speech or crushed by guilt. They find out what their constituency wants — and they give it to them.

American history is full of examples where moral appeals alone failed to bring about change, and where transformation only came once power shifted on the ground. Take the abolition of slavery.

For decades, abolitionists like William Lloyd Garrison and Frederick Douglass filled the air with fiery speeches and scathing indictments of America’s sin. Their words pricked consciences, but slavery endured. It did not end because Southern planters were shamed into repentance. It ended only after decades of political struggle, the rise of a mass anti-slavery party, and finally a civil war that rearranged the balance of power. Moral exhortation lit a fire, yes, of course, but it was power, not guilt, that settled the question.