Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Times Opinion: Must the Tennessee MAGA be taken so seriously?

Staff photo by Mason Edwards / Hamilton County Young Republicans chair Mary Francis Hoots and Hamilton County Republican Party chair Gail Greene spoke as students and community members gathered Tuesday inside the Maclellan Gym to remember Charlie Kirk on his birthday. Oct. 14, 2025.
Staff photo by Mason Edwards / Hamilton County Young Republicans chair Mary Francis Hoots and Hamilton County Republican Party chair Gail Greene spoke as students and community members gathered Tuesday inside the Maclellan Gym to remember Charlie Kirk on his birthday. Oct. 14, 2025.

Over the past decade, the Make America Great Again movement has overtaken the Republican Party and earned the trust, for now, of its fervent base — a powerful yet minority coalition. The popular majority in opposition, fractured across numerous points of contention, has been stuck with the unfortunate task of reassembling the civic fabric torn by this toxic movement.

One approach, all too common in this dystopian era, is to treat MAGA as a serious political project with legitimate grievances. But this outdated line of thinking is a fool’s errand. Appealing to the lowest common denominator is to resign oneself to a never-ending race to the bottom.

Now is the time for staunch opposition, not for feckless capitulation. To tap into a voting bloc increasingly against President Donald Trump’s agenda will require us to see MAGA for what it truly is: an anti-democratic force built on misinformation and outright lies, a faux-populist movement that can and should be defiantly dismissed.

Looking at MAGA’s broader aims and what underpins its motivations reveals an overarching mindset that cannot possibly be reasoned with nor negotiated with in good faith.

To see this in practice, look no further than the absurd cruelty of perhaps the proudest purveyor of MAGA in all of America: the Tennessee state GOP.