A quarter-millennium into the American experiment, some of our skepticism of big government has given way to populism and astounding numbers of regulations.
Following British overreach and the weak Articles of Confederation, we found the happy medium of the Constitution — a system made possible not just by separation of powers or rugged individualism, but by the strength of America’s churches, charities, neighborhoods, clubs, local governments and other voluntary associations.
A free people once learned to govern themselves because in some ways, life was governed close to home. Why, then, has the same country now built an administrative state with tentacles reaching into nearly every corner of economic life?
Some say that as a country gets richer, increasingly diverse and more complex, society demands more rules. That’s true, but it misses a deeper change. Churches and other local institutions provide a wide range of services, ranging from childcare to food for the poor. For decades, these and other sources of moral formation, security and local solidarity have been hollowing out. As they wither, Americans ask Washington to fill the void.
Gallup finds that 70% of us deemed religion “very important” in 1965, compared to only 45% in 2023. Church attendance numbers have fallen, and Pew reports that Christians made up 90% of Americans in 1972; today they are about 62%. The religiously unaffiliated grew nearly sixfold. This tends to happen as societies modernize.
