Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge finds murder defendant’s claim of missing documents lacks credibility

Staff photo by Mason Edwards / Lawrence Goodine, 46, reenters a Hamilton County courtroom Aug. 11, 2026, following a judge's review of the legal documents in his cell. Goodine had claimed some of his legal documents were seized at the Hamilton County Jail.
Staff photo by Mason Edwards / Lawrence Goodine, 46, reenters a Hamilton County courtroom Aug. 11, 2026, following a judge's review of the legal documents in his cell. Goodine had claimed some of his legal documents were seized at the Hamilton County Jail.

A Hamilton County judge denied a motion Tuesday from a Chattanooga man accused of murder after privately reviewing documents recovered from the defendant’s jail cell.

During a pretrial hearing, Lawrence Goodine’s defense attorney, Neil Pinkston, said Goodine did not have certain legal documents needed for trial, which remains scheduled for Monday. The lawyer said the defense would not be ready, and he filed a motion to compel.

Law enforcement accused Goodine, who was fired as a Chattanooga police officer in 2007, of killing Kara Akins, 48, on Nov. 28, 2024. A Hamilton County medical examiner ruled her death a homicide by manual strangulation and blunt force head injury.

(READ MORE: Chattanooga man indicted in girlfriend’s killing)

Since April, Pinkston raised what he said were ongoing concerns about undelivered and seized legal documents and missed attorney-client meetings. In June, he argued the issues Goodine has with the jail were obstructing pretrial preparations.