Starting next summer, Georgia’s highest court will no longer routinely hear appeals in murder cases.
The decision was announced Thursday as part of a concurring opinion from Chief Justice Nels Peterson that was tied to a murder case out of Fulton County, Coleman v. The State, though it was not clear why Peterson’s opinion was attached to that case.
Murder conviction appeals, which account for more than half of the Georgia Supreme Court’s published cases, will now be heard in the Georgia Court of Appeals starting July 2027.
Under Georgia law, the state’s high court has jurisdiction over all capital cases — that is, cases where the death penalty has been imposed. But the question of which court has jurisdiction over cases where the death penalty has not been sought has been a matter of judicial interpretation rather than law dating back to 1983, when the state’s current constitution was adopted.
Though numerous opinions since then have questioned the high court’s role in deciding these cases — including one from last year — the justices have continued to hear and issue rulings in murder cases not involving the death penalty. But in his concurring opinion, Peterson called for an end to the longstanding practice, which he said takes up too much of the court’s workload and results in too many binding precedents.
