In November, I halted a rehearsal and walked out.
My choir was preparing for our winter concert at Chicago’s Symphony Center. Thousands would attend the two performances. But the singers really struggled with Samuel Barber’s haunting “Agnus Dei,” which was to accompany huge overhead photographs of loved ones that our singers and staff had recently lost.
It was exquisitely difficult music for young voices. Eight parts simultaneously sung with no section carried by another. It required something teenagers don’t always possess at 5 p.m. after school, or first thing Saturday mornings: focus, patience and collaboration.
The kids sounded like a slow-motion train wreck. Some attempted to muscle through off-key. Others closed their mouths when harmonies got complicated. This persisted, and I realized they had neither memorized the song nor practiced it, as they had been asked.
“Is this just too hard?” I finally asked the group. “Are you committed to doing the work this piece requires?”
