The Supreme Court has recognized the Federal Reserve as a special case among the government’s numerous independent agencies — one that requires protection from White House interference. The distinction is less than clear-cut in legal terms. As a practical matter, however, preserving the central bank’s independence in monetary policy is vital and should be welcomed unreservedly.
Last week, the six conservative justices united against the court’s three liberals in finding, in effect, that the president can fire members of the Federal Trade Commission (and, it follows, most other independent agencies) at will. At the same time, the liberals plus Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh voted to block the president’s attempt to sack Lisa Cook, a Fed governor, “for cause.”
As Justice Amy Coney Barrett noted in her dissent regarding the Fed, the two decisions appear to be “in serious tension.” If the very idea of independent agencies violates the constitutional separation of powers, as the FTC ruling contends, what makes the Fed so special? And if the answer is that exposing the Fed to political pressure would cause great harm, why shouldn’t that factor carry the same weight when it comes to other agencies?
Rather than resolving such questions, the court has swerved around them. In the FTC case, the court found that agencies, once created by Congress, are part of the executive and not a fourth branch of government. As such, they’re accountable to the president, and hence to the electorate. In the second, the majority focused less on the harm that denying Fed independence would cause than on strained historic understandings about “national banks” and procedural defects in the administration’s efforts to get its way.
It seems that Roberts, author of both opinions, has tried once again to strike a balance between the conservatives’ understanding of strict constitutional propriety and real-world consequences. Time will tell whether placing the FTC and other bodies more squarely under the president’s thumb will be to the nation’s advantage.
