Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Times Opinion: Facts don’t win elections. Stories do

Photo by Laura Brett via Getty Images/TNS / One of the many signs throughout the polling sites informing voters where to go as New Yorkers head to the polls on Primary Day June 23, 2026, in New York City.
Photo by Laura Brett via Getty Images/TNS / One of the many signs throughout the polling sites informing voters where to go as New Yorkers head to the polls on Primary Day June 23, 2026, in New York City.

As a student, I was taught that politics is a contest of ideas. Experience has shown me otherwise.

In a recent interview, conservative activist Chris Rufo captured this: “While we should have the facts on our side, and while we should use logic, by itself, it’s insufficient. Politics operates on a deeper level, an emotional level. Politics occurs on the field of sentiment and public opinion much more than on the field of abstract argumentation.”

That may unsettle many Democrats. Yet it aligns with decades of research. Voters rarely decide by weighing policy papers or fact-checking speeches. They respond to stories about who they are, what threatens them and where the country is headed.

This helps explain one of the Democratic Party’s central challenges in the Trump era. For years, Democrats have assumed elections are won through evidence and detailed plans. President Donald Trump has operated differently. With the instincts of an entertainer, he leads with narrative, treating facts as optional and subordinate to the story he wants to tell.

This is not a call for Democrats to abandon facts or embrace demagoguery. Governing demands evidence, expertise and compromise. Campaigns require something more fundamental: a story that convinces people their lives can change.