Over the weekend, the Food and Drug Administration sent Americans trying to navigate the cyclospora outbreak into a tailspin. A day after Taylor Farms announced a voluntary recall of iceberg lettuce in 27 states — generating one set of alarming headlines — the FDA said that a test linking the company’s lettuce to the parasite had been wrong, leading to seemingly contradictory coverage.
Americans are understandably confused. What exactly is going on?
The false positive doesn’t mean Taylor Farms is in the clear. Evidence from infected people still points to its iceberg lettuce as the likely source of at least part of the nationwide outbreak of cyclosporiasis, which has sickened thousands with “explosive” diarrhea. Taylor Farms hasn’t walked back its recall.
But you might not know that from the latest round of agency communications.
While some uncertainty is inevitable in a fast-moving outbreak, confusion on this scale is not. When consumers want to understand how to protect themselves, the FDA and CDC should serve as reliable guides. Now, though, Americans too often feel they’re muddling through on their own. Rather than proactively explaining what they do and don’t know, federal health agencies are reacting only after confusion has taken hold. This mixed messaging has left people unsure what to eat — or who to trust.
