Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Toni Says: Why is my Medicare monthly premium over $700?

Hi Toni,

I enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan with a $0 monthly premium that began June 1 because I turned 65 on June 5. I disenrolled from my husband’s employer benefits since the Advantage plan’s monthly premium was lower than what my husband was charged.

Now I am in shock because a Medicare premium of $732.50 was deducted from my Social Security check. I was told by the agent who enrolled me in the Advantage plan that my premium would be $0.

My husband, Jack, is 63 and wants to continue working until he is 70. He is working for a local bank and has a nice salary. Since he is still working full-time, I may have made a mistake by enrolling in this Medicare Advantage plan and leaving his employer plan. I cannot return to his plan until January. Can you please explain what I did wrong?

— Brenda from Myrtle Beach, North Carolina