Skip to main content
Thursday, October 29, 2026Oct 29

This story is exclusive to subscribers.

Chattanooga to settle negligent crash lawsuit involving police car for $250K

Staff file photo by Matt Hamilton / A Chattanooga police cruiser is pictured. The city has settled for $250,000 a lawsuit filed by a motorist who was involved in a wreck with a police car that was responding to an emergency.
Staff file photo by Matt Hamilton / A Chattanooga police cruiser is pictured. The city has settled for $250,000 a lawsuit filed by a motorist who was involved in a wreck with a police car that was responding to an emergency. Staff file photo by Matt Hamilton / A Chattanooga police cruiser is pictured. The city has settled for $250,000 a lawsuit filed by a motorist who was involved in a wreck with a police car that was responding to an emergency.

After the first day of trial, the city announced it would settle for $250,000 a lawsuit that accused a Chattanooga police officer of running a red light and hitting a motorist.

Shirley Trotter originally asked for almost $3 million, accusing officer Frisco Sherrill of negligently causing a wreck Dec. 16, 2022, leaving her with permanent injuries and forcing her into assisted living care for a time, court records said.

In response to the suit, the city denied liability and said Sherrill was responding to a shots-fired emergency with lights and siren activated around five seconds before driving through the intersection of Hickory Valley Road and Shallowford Road, according to court records.

(READ MORE: Judge denies Erlanger’s requests to dismiss alleged illegal kickbacks lawsuit)

Around one minute after receiving the call at 8:29 a.m., Sherrill activated the lights and siren on his patrol car. The officer said a glare prevented him from determining what color the traffic lights were, according to court records.