I grew up in a home of immigrants from Colombia, Cuba and Peru, and ours was a mixed-status family. Some family members became naturalized citizens thanks to legislation for refugees. Others, such as my mother, were sponsored by spouses. Some, like me, were born here.
We thought — and media confirmed — that once acquired, citizenship was for life. But that’s no longer the case. The Department of Justice recently announced that it would be in court to strip a dozen naturalized Americans of their citizenship, and the department is directing prosecutors to target as many as 384 naturalized Americans. For comparison, since 2017, the Justice Department has moved to denaturalize at least 120 people. The citizenship status of 26 million naturalized Americans is no longer guaranteed.
Americans are generally only in danger of losing their citizenship if they are found guilty of committing fraud on their naturalization applications, but in January, President Donald Trump told reporters his administration was considering another factor: countries of origin. During Trump’s first presidency, journalist Seth Freed Wessler found that people from Yemen, Somalia and Iran make up only about 1% of the foreign-born population in the U.S., but they were about 10% of the citizens the Trump administration tried to denaturalize in 2017 and 2018. Trump has also identified the predominantly white countries from which he would like to welcome immigrants: Norway, Sweden and Denmark.
During his first administration, Trump created the Denaturalization Section as part of the Justice Department. In 2020, multiple federal agencies busied themselves sending the new unit the names of more than 500 people who could be investigated for citizenship fraud. Norma Borgoño had been naturalized for more than a decade and had been living in the country since 1989 — Trump wanted to denaturalize her because she had been convicted of a white-collar crime years after becoming a citizen. The Justice Department eventually dropped the case, but the point was clear: No one was safe from scrutiny.
If citizenship can be taken away, was it ever real?
