Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Attorneys call for Tennessee death penalty pause after ‘barbaric’ failed execution

Federal public defender Amy Harwell speaks at a press conference during which attorneys called for a halt to executions in Tennessee until a legal challenge to the lethal injection protocol is resolved. (Martin B. Cherry/Nashville Banner)
Federal public defender Amy Harwell speaks at a press conference during which attorneys called for a halt to executions in Tennessee until a legal challenge to the lethal injection protocol is resolved. (Martin B. Cherry/Nashville Banner)

This story was originally published by the Nashville Banner. Sign up for their newsletter at nashvillebanner.com/newsletters.

______

Attorneys for Tony Carruthers urged Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee to pause the state’s death penalty days after executioners failed to place IV lines for Carruthers’ lethal injection.

Lee issued a one-year reprieve for Carruthers, whose attorneys now say he should do the same for three other people — including the only woman on Tennessee’s death row — scheduled for execution in the state this year. At a press conference Tuesday, they said that a pause was needed to allow their 2025 legal challenge of the state’s new lethal injection protocol filed on behalf of Kevin Burns and several other death row inmates to be fully heard by the courts.

Assistant federal public defender Amy Harwell, who represents Carruthers, said what happened to him was “not just foreseeable — it was, in fact, foreseen.”