A real estate investment trust, or REIT, is a unique corporate structure that is designed to own or operate income-producing real estate or hold real estate-related debt. Congress created the structure in 1960 so individual investors could gain exposure to commercial properties by investing in companies specifically designed to manage real estate. The concept is similar to mutual funds and ETFs that provide ordinary investors with access to a portfolio of stocks and bonds. REITs operate
under different tax rules that make them attractive to income-oriented investors but also may complicate matters at tax time.
To qualify as a real estate investment trust, a company must invest at least 75% of its assets in real property, cash or Treasuries, and derive at least 75% of its gross income from rents, mortgage interest, or property sales. It must also have at least 100 shareholders and be governed by a board of directors or trustees.
Most importantly, it must pay out at least 90% of its taxable income to shareholders each year. If it meets these requirements, a REIT can avoid taxation at the corporate level, passing through its net income to holders of stock in the company. This differs fundamentally from most public companies, which pay income tax on their earnings, then distribute a portion of net profits as dividends to shareholders that are taxed a second time at the individual level. Avoiding double taxation can mean higher cash payments to shareholders who understand and appreciate the risks and tax implications.
Before 1960, investing in commercial real estate was largely the domain of wealthy individuals, family partnerships, insurance companies and pension funds. Early real estate trusts had enjoyed favorable tax treatment in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, but changes in federal tax law during the 1930s subjected many of these entities to corporate taxation. This effectively eliminated much of the tax advantage that had made the structure attractive.
Although the real estate industry subsequently sought legislation that would restore pass-through tax treatment, President Dwight D. Eisenhower vetoed the first significant REIT bill in 1956, expressing concern over potential loss of federal tax revenue. Four years later, Ike had gotten on board and signed a bill creating the modern real estate investment trust structure. Characteristically, Congress buried the REIT provisions deep within the Cigar Excise Tax Extension Act of 1960. Today, there are around 200 publicly traded REITs valued at over $2.5 trillion. The S&P 500 index holds 28 real estate trusts.
There are two broad classes of real estate trusts. Equity REITs own physical property and collect rent. They make up the bulk of the market and span many sectors including residential apartments and rental homes, industrial warehouses and logistics centers, healthcare facilities, retail shopping centers and office properties. Specialty segments have expanded in recent years including cell towers and data centers.
With most equity REITs, depreciation is a significant income statement expense that reduces earnings but is not a cash expense. Therefore, reported earnings understate free cash flow. Analysts therefore favor “funds from operations,” or FFO, which adds depreciation back and strips out property sale gains to better approximate cash available to distribute to shareholders. This metric is especially important in evaluating the sustainability of payouts.
Mortgage REITs (mREITs) do not own physical real estate but hold mortgages or mortgage-backed securities, which tend to sport higher average yields but come with additional risk as well. Many use leverage to juice up the payout but note that leverage works both ways and can also magnify losses.
Diversified equity REIT funds are often at the lower end of the risk spectrum and carry more modest yields as a result. Think slower growing, more mature sectors such as net-lease warehouse, office and traditional retail sectors.
Mortgage REITs sit at the extreme end of the spectrum, with some yielding 9% to 10% or more. That yield is compensation for real risks: leverage, sensitivity to interest-rate swings, and credit exposure. Many mREITs have been forced to cut dividends and have lost substantial share value during periods of stress. An eye-watering payout can be quickly wiped out if the principal value declines.
Since REITs distribute most of their annual income, they generally retain very little capital for expansion and must rely on issuing additional shares or borrowing in order to purchase additional properties or mortgages, making them more sensitive to interest rates and capital markets. REIT yields are generally higher than those of the broader stock market, but the dividend alone should not be the only criterion.
In addition to attractive yields, REITs also come with tax considerations that investors should consider carefully. Most REIT dividends are taxed as ordinary income, not at the lower rates that apply to qualified dividends on many stocks. For someone in a high bracket, that can gobble up a meaningful slice of the yield. There is partial relief: Shareholders can generally deduct up to 20% of qualified REIT dividends, helping to offset some of the pain.
Your year-end tax report, form 1099, may also show other types of distributions for real estate holdings. Return of capital may be distributed if the payout is greater than earnings. Return of capital is not taxable but reduces the cost basis, increasing the eventual capital gain when you sell. REITs may also occasionally pay out capital gains distributions, usually subject to 15% taxation if they are classified as long term (over one year).
Because of the ordinary-income treatment, many investors prefer to hold REITs in tax-advantaged accounts like IRAs and 401(k)s.
Real estate investment trusts offer commercial property exposure, liquidity, and diversification as a complement to traditional stocks and bonds and frequently feature attractive income yields in relation to their risks. In addition to a wide array of individual REITs, investors can select from a large selection of professionally managed real estate funds to gain access to many REITs in a single package. A modest, targeted allocation in a balanced portfolio is worthy of consideration.
Christopher A. Hopkins, CFA, is a co-founder of Apogee Wealth Partners in Chattanooga.
